Health Grantmakers Address Disparities, Focus on Impact

February 1, 2012

MCF’s third webinar in our 2012 grantmaking outlook series focused on funding for health. We reviewed recent trends in health giving and the subject area outlook for 2012. Then Bill King, MCF president, discussed health grantmaking with Jacob Gayle, vice president and executive director, Medtronic Foundation, and Joan Oswald, grants specialist, Miller-Dwan Foundation.

These health philanthropy leaders emphasized the importance of addressing disparities in health access and outcomes. Gayle described Medtronic’s focus: “We are trying to enable greater access to healthcare for populations that otherwise have been left out.”

He added, “We always have to keep diversity in the fore of our minds as we do funding. If we find we are missing some segment of the population, we will reach out to partners for recommendations on how to address that.”

Both grantmakers expressed strongly that philanthropy’s role should not be to fill gaps in public sector funding. Oswald noted, “There is just no way one philanthropic organization or even a partnership could tackle healthcare costs covered by the public sector.”

Gayle commented, “Philanthropy is able to go into areas that are unproven. We can make longer-term and sustained commitments to grantees. And philanthropy has the flexibility to make mistakes and learn from them. It’s not the role of philanthropy to step in where others have grown weary of funding. It’s to play the innovative, out-of-the-box partner.”

Both Gayle and Oswald see grantmakers becoming even more strategic as they seek to leverage grant dollars for meaningful results. As funding stays flat, Oswald said, it’s important to stick to goals. “We are working diligently to assure our funding is very targeted and a really clear match for our priorities.”

Gayle noted that Medtronic Foundation is focused on developing and strengthening health systems. “Much of our funding is going toward overall policy articulation and advocacy, development of the health infrastructure, and strengthening of healthcare deliverers, as opposed to direct services,” he explained.

Nonprofits that find the current fundraising environment challenging can look for creative ways to finance their programs. Gayle suggested: “Think about nontraditional sources of funding — local companies, other service organizations, fraternities and sororities, or professional organizations can provide as much – or even more – support than local philanthropies.” He added that sometimes health causes are perceived as social services. So see if what you’re trying to fund is defined differently by different organizations.

When approaching grantmakers, nonprofits should do their homework, but be ready to have an open conversation. Oswald noted, “Be at your very best. Really clearly explain what you’re looking for and how that fits with our priorities. When the pieces all fall into place, we are absolutely willing to work with you, even if you are completely unfamiliar with the grantmaking process.”

And Gayle encouraged nonprofits, “Take a chance. Don’t let a ‘no’ ever stop you.”

Last Outlook Webinar to Focus on Arts, Culture and Humanities

The final Outlook webinar, taking place on February 7, will delve deeply into arts funding.  It will feature conversations with grantmakers from Minnesota Philanthropy Partners and The McKnight Foundation.

Register today to learn more about Minnesota’s funding landscape in 2012!

-Anne Bauers, MCF research manager


“Us vs. Them”: Shine a Light on Your Own Biases

January 27, 2012

Despite decades of diversity training, have our organizations and our society changed for the better?

Turn on or tune in to any media source, and your emphatic reply would be “No way.” The extreme polarization in our country is more and more frightening every day. The new cultural norm is to not merely express strong points of view but to thoroughly demonize others.

At least one practitioner says it’s time to address this crisis with a new, 21st century approach to diversity, inclusion and equity.

At the University of St. Thomas Diversity Insights program last Thursday, Howard Ross, founder of Cook Ross Inc. and a leading national expert on diversity, leadership, and organizational change, challenged his audience to look within themselves for solutions.

Ross homed in on the source of our animosity toward each other — essentially, primal fears that lead us toward unconscious, visceral negative reactions to cultural, group, individual and institutional differences.

He coached audience members to overcome the “us vs. them” mentality by developing our capacity to observe ourselves. Instead of pointing the finger at others, he said, we should shine a light on our own biases.  Recognizing our own foibles and faults will increase our compassion toward others.

Ross’s points reminded me of conversations we’ve had at MCF about diversity in philanthropy. When we developed our Diversity & Inclusion Action Kit to accompany MCF’s Working Towards Diversity IV research, we deliberately titled the worksheets ”My Actions.” We wanted to reinforce that grantmakers must take the first step by focusing on what they can do – not what others should do.

Ross concluded his remarks with some concrete steps we can each take to close the widening gulfs in our organizations and in society at large:

  • Shift your consumption of media to really listen to the other side.
  • Open a constructive dialogue in your organization, focusing not on the issues themselves, but on the way in which you’re talking about the issues.
  • Talk to young people about other points of view.
  • Take “the other” to lunch not to persuade, but to listen.

I haven’t cracked open Ross’s new book “ReInventing Diversity: Transforming Organizational Community to Strengthen People, Purpose and Performance.” But based on his presentation, I expect I’ll find more than a few concepts that are applicable to the nonprofit and philanthropic sectors.

Join the Conversation: When “us vs. them” differences arise in your own organization, what are your actions and reactions? Is there a chasm between grantmakers and nonprofits that could be narrowed by self-awareness?

- Wendy Wehr, MCF v.p. of communications and information services

Photo cc AAskew


Make the Most of 2012 with Impact and Shared Learning

January 24, 2012

Today in the second in our series of webinars on the 2012 grantmaking outlook, we focused on human services funding. Upcoming sessions include health and arts.

We reviewed recent trends in human services giving and the subject area outlook for 2012. Then Bill King, MCF president, talked with Neal Cuthbert, vice president of program, The McKnight Foundation, and Randi Roth, executive director, Otto Bremer Foundation.

These leading grantmakers acknowledged the difficult funding landscape. Roth explained, “Needs are dramatically outstripping resources. In the communities, the economic conditions are more difficult than you could remedy with the amount of money that’s available. Last year’s donors are this year’s recipients.”

Added Cuthbert, “The human services arena has really been challenging not only because of the recession but because of what’s been going on in the public sector. There’s political stasis and an inability for the public sector to move forward.”

These challenges aside, Roth and Cuthbert offered some perspective and insight for grantseekers in 2012:

  • Everyone’s focused on greater impact. “These communities need help. You only have so many dollars and you want them to go as far as possible. Impact is really just a way of being cost effective,” noted Roth. Both panelists agreed that defining and measuring impact is difficult. Cuthbert said, “We try to really focus on and articulate the two or three areas where we want to see change.”
  • To achieve more impact, grantmakers and nonprofits are creating opportunities for shared learning and collaboration. As Roth described, “Is one model proven to be effective and can this information be shared between grant applicants? Can a program that’s doing a good job share those best practices?” Cuthbert explained, “We expect ourselves to be constantly learning and we expect it of the people we work with.”

So how can nonprofits more successfully partner with grantmakers in 2012? Roth summarized, “Tell us how your work will move this community forward, tell us how you’ll know you’re successful, and tell us where you fit into the network of service providers.” She added, “As a grantmaker you don’t expect the same level of sophistication in answering these questions from a very small organization as from a very large one. But I think you still have the conversation on the same topics. Even the smallest organization in the most remote place does need to be thinking about these things.”

Cuthbert summed up, “You have to be brutally pragmatic, as nimble as you can possibly be, flexible and opportunistic.”

Other Grantmakers to Share Advice

Two more upcoming webinars will delve deeply into health and arts funding.  They will feature conversations with grantmakers from Medtronic Foundation, Miller-Dwan Foundation, Minnesota Philanthropy Partners, and The McKnight Foundation.

Register today to learn more about Minnesota’s funding landscape in 2012!

-Anne Bauers, MCF research manager


First-Hand Insights on 2012 Education Grantmaking

January 18, 2012

MCF today hosted the first of four webinars reviewing grantmakers’ giving outlook for 2012. Our topic today was education. Upcoming sessions include human services, health and arts.

We reviewed recent trends in education giving and the grantmaker outlook for 2012. Then Bill King, MCF president, chatted with Mike Newman, vice president and director of community relations, Travelers Foundation, and Susan Heegard, vice president and educational team leader, Bush Foundation. These leading grantmakers described several important trends in education grantmaking for 2012:

  • Grantmakers will continue to focus on collaboration as a way to share learning opportunities with partners, leverage resources, and prevent duplication. Heegard explained, “If there are other folks working in this area, we want to make sure that we’re adding value and figuring out carefully where our niche is.” Newman added, “We as a philanthropic sector, along with the nonprofit sector, are learning how to better connect with one another.”
  • One benefit of collaboration is enabling grantmakers and nonprofits to be learning organizations. “Learning – and sharing that learning with others – is really critical, whether you have success or not,” said Heegard.
  • Data will continue to drive grantmaker decision making. Heegard noted, “You want to use data to guide the front-end decision: How should you invest? And then you want to use data to track your progress: how are you doing?”
  • Even as collaboration becomes increasingly important, Newman noted that grantmakers will continue to fund diverse priorities and programs. Heegard added that this makes sense — to fund across the full spectrum of education needs.

The grantmakers also offered their own advice to nonprofits seeking grants in 2012:

  • Know your own work well. Newman commented, “Be clear about who you are and say it with clarity.”
  • Know your colleagues and potential partners. “Have a good knowledge of who else is doing similar or related work. Distinguish your efforts, or figure out a way to come together with others in partnership,” Heegard said.
  • Understand the grantmaker, including areas of focus. “Check out our website. Talk to colleagues. Find out who else we fund. That gets you a helpful overview,” Newman advised.

One great tool for understanding grantmakers’ guidelines and which nonprofits they’ve supported in the past is MCF’s Minnesota Grantmakers Online.

Other Grantmakers to Share Advice

Three upcoming webinars will delve deeply into other subject areas, and they will feature conversations with grantmakers from The McKnight Foundation, Medtronic Foundation, Miller-Dwan Foundation, Minnesota Philanthropy Partners and Otto Bremer Foundation.

Register today to learn more about Minnesota’s funding landscape in 2012!

-Anne Bauers, MCF research manager


The Changing Faces of Philanthropy

January 17, 2012

A new report, Cultures of Giving, commissioned by MCF member W.K. Kellogg Foundation looks at the recent growth of identity-based philanthropy – defined this way:

A growing movement to spark philanthropic giving from a community on behalf of a community, where “community” is defined by race, ethnicity, gender or sexual orientation.

The U.S. population is changing, with ethnic and racial groups growing faster than the overall population. Not surprisingly, the face of philanthropy is changing along with it.

The report found that 63 percent of Latino households now make charitable donations, and blacks give away 25 percent more of their income per year than whites.

Concurrently the definition of philanthropy is expanding to encompass contributions of any size from people of every income bracket and ethnic background. And, the report shows how these new philanthropists are pooling their money—in increasingly organized ways—for greater impact.

The report challenges funders to consider ways to collaborate:

  • by providing seed support and other forms of assistance,
  • by embracing identity-based funds as critical partners in the sector and forging stronger connections within communities of color,
  • by diversifying the leadership of mainstream philanthropy to reflect changing demographics and
  • by shifting practices to reflect what communities of color are teaching about the future of giving and how funders can positively impact the country’s most vulnerable children and families.

MCF agrees that grantmaking is most effective when grantmakers reflect the diversity of the communities they serve.

For local information on the subject, check out our 2011 Working Towards Diversity IV report, which paints a comprehensive picture of the demographics, policies and practices on diversity and inclusion of Minnesota grantmakers. Review our diversity resources, and visit the websites of our strategic partners:

It’s important work. W.K. Kellogg Foundation president and CEO Sterling Speirn puts it this way, “We believe that understanding and supporting this emerging area of philanthropy is essential for any foundation, funder or donor who wants to drive social change.”

- Susan Stehling, MCF communications associate

CC Photo: KellyCDB


Stability in 2012 Giving – Learn More at a Webinar

January 9, 2012

MCF today reported that the state’s grantmakers expect relatively stable giving in 2012. According to MCF’s 2012 Outlook Report, foundations and corporations believe their grantmaking will remain flat or possibly increase about one percent from 2011.

Seventy percent of grantmakers anticipate that their funding priorities will remain constant in 2012, which is almost a 10-point increase over what they predicted for 2011.

MCF’s 2012 Outlook Report is based on an October/November 2011 survey of 100 foundations and corporate giving programs that represent 76 percent (or about $1 billion) of all Minnesota annual grantmaking.

Subject-Area Funding
For the first time in its annual Outlook survey, MCF asked grantmakers to estimate changes in giving to the specific subject areas they support. While most respondents plan no changes to 2012 subject-area giving, one third of education funders forecast giving more to education in 2012.

Arts, culture, and humanities is the only subject area to which more grantmakers said they expect to decrease rather than increase funding. Although the respondents represent a small part of the Outlook survey sample, this finding appears to be consistent with a trend toward less arts funding as reported in MCF’s latest Giving in Minnesota report.

Learn More
To learn more about what the report findings mean for Minnesota’s nonprofit and philanthropic communities, check out the full report online and register today for one or all four of the subject-specific webinars hosted by MCF.

Webinar topics and dates are:

At each webinar, in addition to a broad overview of 2012’s giving outlook, a panel of funders will dive more deeply into subject-specific funding and answer questions like the following:

  • What are the current trends in funding for education, human services, health or arts?
  • Will funding for the area be up or down in 2012?
  • What should nonprofits be aware of as they prepare to seek funds in 2012?

We promise you’ll come away from them more knowledgeable and informed about 2012’s funding landscape in Minnesota!


The Top 11 of 2011

December 29, 2011

As the year draws to a close, we think it’s worthwhile to take a look back and highlight some of the favorite, most read pieces from the Philanthropy Potluck blog in 2011. From working with program officers to the education gap to teaching kids the value of philanthropy, here are some of our readers’ favorite posts!

  1. Pet Peeves from Program Officers – How to steer clear of some common annoyances in the grantmaker/grantee relationship.
  2. Program Evaluation or Research and Development? – We need both! Six principles for engaging in sound research & development.
  3. Grantmaking at Margaret A. Cargill Philanthropies – Minnesota’s largest grantmaker gears up and starts granting.
  4. Blandin Foundation Names New CEO – We welcome Kathleen Annette to her new role.
  5. What Does It Take to Lead in Diversity and Inclusivity? – Excerpts from an interview with Headwaters Foundation for Justice program director David Nicholson.
  6. High Praise from Program Officers – The flip side of pet peeves: how to make that relationship a good one!
  7. Youthprise Launches to Champion Learning Beyond the Classroom – A new grantmaker and MCF member hits the scene.
  8. Five Critical Ways to Address the Education Gap – Recommendations from the Minnesota African American Leadership Forum.
  9. We All Lose: Impact of Deep Cuts to NEA – Thoughts on arts-related cuts passed in Congress earlier this year.
  10. Native Americans in Philanthropy Giving Research Shows Inequities – Some bad news (national funding to Native Americans is low), and some good (Minnesota-based grantees receive the largest share of grant dollars targeting Native Americans in the nation).
  11. Teaching Kids to Share, Save and Spend – Some lessons from Teach Your Kids to Share Day, presented by MCF member Thrivent Financial for Lutherans.

Join the conversation: What were your favorite blog posts of 2011?


Six Reasons We’re Thankful This Week

November 23, 2011

The week of Thanksgiving is a great time for all of us to pause and reflect on the good things happening in our lives and our community. With that in mind, we thought we’d share some things that crossed our desks this week here at MCF, that give us reason to say thanks:

  • The Nonprofit Research Collaborative has released its Summer/Early Fall 2011 fundraising survey. It found that 44 percent of responding charities reported increases in funds raised. Fifty percent of human service organizations saw an increase in funds raised.
  • Giving USA found total estimated charitable giving in the United States rose 3.8% in 2010. Total charitable giving for 2010 is estimated to be $290.89 billion. This was the first increase since 2007.
  • Giving in Numbers 2011 Edition, produced by the Committee Encouraging Corporate Philanthropy, found that the 183 responding companies gave an average of $22.1 million in 2010. 94% of these companies offered at least one matching gift program.
  • Preparing our children for school success is possible. According to MCF member The Minneapolis Foundation, Minneapolis has seen a 13% increase in the number of children entering kindergarten ready to learn in the past three years.
  • In the Annie E. Casey Foundation 2011 KIDS COUNT Data Book, Minnesota ranked second in the country in child well-being, after only New Hampshire.
  • A report from another member, The McKnight Foundation, found that since 2004, public-private partnership Heading Home Minnesota has obtained funding for 3,146 new housing opportunities for families and individuals. That’s an increase of 79 percent in the past four years.

Join the conversation: What pieces of good news are you thankful for?

Happy Thanksgiving!

Photo cc Robleto

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,428 other followers