Evaluation: Make It Meaningful and Useful

May 17, 2013
Michael Quinn Patton

Michael Quinn Patton

Don’t miss MCF’s spring issue of Giving Forum, online and in your mailbox now, for “Making Evaluation Meaningful and Useful” by Michael Quinn Patton.

He says, “High-performing organizations make evaluative thinking a way of doing business.”

He distills 40 years of experience conducting evaluation, training evaluators and writing about evaluation into three important lessons. Here’s a taste. There’s much more in the complete Commentary.

  1. Embedded Evaluative Thinking Creates Lasting Impact: Patton stresses that the first step is distinguishing evaluative thinking from doing an evaluation and says, “Evaluation is an activity that produces reports; evaluative thinking produces effective organizations.”
  2. Evaluation is a Leadership Responsibility and Function: Evaluation must not be seen as a technical or administrative function. Instead it is an ongoing inquiry into what works — for whom, in what ways and under what conditions– that must become a strategic priority.
  3. Evaluating Your Organization’s Evaluation Culture Deepens It: This step involves asking tough questions of your staff: How is evaluation viewed here? How are failures handled? What would you tell a new co-worker about how to approach evaluation?

He also shares a bit about his work over the last year with the Otto Bremer Foundation, an MCF member, as it works to embed evaluative thinking into its culture.

He mentions a set of 25 Evaluation Flash Cards that the foundation put together to summarize key evaluation concepts and their implications for grantmaking. The flash cards will soon be available on the Otto Bremer Foundation website as a resource for the philanthropic and nonprofit community. We’re anxious to see them too, so we’ll let you know when we hear that they’ve been posted.

The spring issue of Giving Forum is all evaluation, measurement and results, so don’t miss it!

- Susan Stehling, MCF communications associate


Foundation Program Officers Talk Evaluation

April 19, 2013

gfbannerDon’t miss the spring issue of MCF’s Giving Forum, where our brand new lead article represents a complete conversation we had with program officers: “Gauging Impact and Using Feedback.” In addition we’ve re-posted the video segment that you may have seen on the Philanthropy Potluck BlogPollen or MinnPost.

But Giving Forum online is the only place to both read the article and watch the video.

In the pieces, program officers from MCF-member foundations answer questions about:

  • how they evaluate grants and grantees,
  • how they obtain and use grant results,
  • what they’ve changed based on grantee feedback,
  • how they share the results,
  • why they think it is important for nonprofits to build evaluation into their work and more.

The insights of program officers from the following foundations are included:

How do you use evaluation at your foundation or nonprofit? Let us know.

- Susan Stehling, MCF communications associate


McKnight Focuses on Midwest Climate, Energy

April 10, 2013

logo_mcknight_200This week MCF member The McKnight Foundation announced a new strategic focus to make the Midwest a leader in addressing climate change.

The new Midwest Climate & Energy program complements over 20 years of McKnight support for renewable energy in Minnesota and the Midwest. Aimee Witteman will direct the new initiative.

“Over the past five years, McKnight has invested over $60 million globally through the ClimateWorks Foundation network, which has yielded major advances in carbon reduction and helped draw other funding into key areas around the world,” noted Kate Wolford, foundation president. “Now building on the Foundation’s history as a place-based funder, we will concentrate attention and funding in the Midwest.”

“America’s Midwest contributes 22 percent more greenhouse gas emissions per capita than the national average,” explained McKnight board chair Ted Staryk. “With the right vision and collaboration, we have an opportunity now to use the Midwest’s industries, geography, and bipartisan political will to our advantage for greater economic prosperity and an overall better regional future.”

$25 Million in Grants Announced
McKnight is jumpstarting the Midwest Climate & Energy program with $25 million in funding to two key partners:

  • RE-AMP received $5 million over two years to promote policies in the Upper Midwest that advance clean energy and combat climate change. A grantee since 2004, RE-AMP is a network of more than 150 nonprofits and 14 foundations working in eight Midwest states to reduce pollution that causes climate change.
  • Energy Foundation, San Francisco, received $20 million over two years to win new clean energy policies in the Midwest and reshape the national narrative around energy and climate. McKnight has partnered with EF since 1993, with a primary focus on public policies to encourage markets for renewable energy and energy efficiency.

Public, Private Integrated Approach
McKnight’s climate-related work will engage the region’s public and private leaders, decisionmakers, and communities. Key objectives are:

  • Climate and energy policy: Support for grantees and networks to advance related Midwest policies in energy generation, efficiency, transmission, agriculture, and transportation.
  • Community engagement: Support to advance community-level efforts that promote energy and transportation efficiency, and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Resilient clean energy economy: Support to facilitate private-sector leaders and networks to develop, promote, and implement climate and energy objectives for the Midwest.

For more, read the Star Tribune’s coverage of the announcement or visit The McKnight Foundation website.



Your Chance to Recognize Excellence in Philanthropy

January 10, 2013

ncrp_logo_fDo you work with grantmaking organizations that lead by example every day and represent the best things about the field of philanthropy? Here’s your chance to recognize them for their efforts!

The National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP) is currently seeking nominations for its Excellence in Philanthropy Awards. These awards will honor grantmaking organizations that have made special contributions to:

  • Attack the root causes of social problems
  • Empower underserved communities
  • Improve the sector as a whole through public leadership

One award will be given out to each of four different types of grantmakers: large private foundations. small/mid-size private foundations, corporate foundations, and grantmaking public charities (such as community and public foundations). Individuals can nominate up to three grantmakers for each award.

Make your nominations through NCRP’s online form, and encourage others to do the same! Let’s spread the word about all the good work being done by grantmakers in Minnesota. The deadline to submit is February 1, 2013, so put your thinking caps on now.


Minnesota Grantmakers Optimistic About 2013

January 7, 2013

2013outlookbMCF reported today that Minnesota grantmakers forecast slightly higher giving in 2013. According to the 2013 Outlook Report, foundations and corporations believe their grantmaking will increase about 2% from 2012.

According to MCF’s Giving in Minnesota research, Minnesota grantmakers give approximately $1.4 billion each year to charities and scholarship recipients.

Education Giving May Grow

In the Outlook survey, MCF asked grantmakers to estimate changes in giving to specific subject areas they support.

  • Most (82 of 104) respondents plan to support education causes in 2013.
  • And 25 of the 82 plan to boost funding to education.

Support for Racial, Ethnic Populations Evident

MCF also queried grantmakers on their plans to support specific populations in 2013.

  • Most (82 of 104) respondents indicated their giving benefits racial and ethnic minority groups.
  • Other key constituencies on which grantmakers will focus include economically disadvantaged populations and children or youth.

Optimism for Assets

Grantmakers are slightly more optimistic than last year about the outlook for asset values.

  • 56% of foundations expect their assets to grow in 2013, versus 45% who projected increases during 2012.
  • Almost 33% of foundations anticipate assets will remain constant in 2013.

Learn More at Webinar

MCF will host a webinar January 16 to detail the 2013 Outlook Report findings and provide additional context about the overall economic climate.

Bob Tracy, MCF’s director of government relations and public policy, will discuss how state and federal policy priorities will impact the nonprofit and philanthropic sectors.

For webinar details and to register, visit www.mcf.org/events.

Read the Full Report

Read the complete 2013 Outlook Report, including an analysis of anticipated giving by grantmakers of different sizes and types, and descriptions of non-cash support strategies: www.mcf.org/research/outlook.

The 2013 Outlook Report is based on a late 2012 survey of 104 foundations and corporate giving programs that represent 75 percent of all Minnesota annual grantmaking.

- Susan Stehling, communications associate, MCF


Your Chance to Vote on the Innovation Award Finalists

December 10, 2012

lgi_pnlc_logo_with_incommons_2012Congratulations to Dakota County Community Services, Irondale High School of Mounds View Public Schools and the City of St. Paul, the finalists in the Humphrey School of Public Affairs/InCommons Local Government Innovation Awards!

A public vote will determine which one of these finalists will receive a $25,000 grant to continue innovating.In addition to the three finalists, 15 other local government entries will receive awards for their innovations.

InCommons and the Humphrey School invite you to help in helping select the $25,000 grant recipient by attending a community conversation to learn and share about local government innovation.

These events are an opportunity to talk with local government officials and to connect with others interested in supporting and improving the work that our schools, cities, and counties do every day. Everyone who attends a community conversation in December will have a chance to vote for which of the three finalists should receive the $25,000 grant.

Three are coming up:

  • December 13 with Dakota County Community Services: 9:30 am to 11:30 am at the Rosemount Community Center.
  • December 18 with Irondale High School: 11:00 am to 12:30 pm at the TIES Building in Saint Paul.
  • December 19 with the City of Saint Paul’s EMS Academy: 2:00 pm to 4:00 pm at Fire Station 51 in Saint Paul.

Visit the InCommons website to learn more about the Awards and to see how the finalists and award recipients have been making Minnesota better by doing things differently.



Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,445 other followers